How Traffic Changed When Google Pulled Our Author and Video Snippets
In the past 2 months Google made big changes to its search results.
Webmasters saw disappearing Google authorship photos, reduced video snippets, changes to local packs and in-depth articles, and more.
Here at Moz, we've closely monitored our own URLs to measure the effect of these changes on our actual traffic. The results surprised us.
Authorship traffic—surprising results
In the early days of authorship, many webmasters worked hard to get their photo in Google search results. I confess, I doubt anyone worked harder at author snippets than me.
Search results soon became crowded with smiling faces staring back at us. Authors hired professional photographers. Publishers worked to correctly follow Google's guidelines to set up authorship for thousands of authors.
The race for more clicks was on.
Then on June 28th, Google cleared the page. No more author photos.
To gauge the effect on traffic, we examined eight weeks' worth of data from Google Analytics and Webmaster Tools, before and after the change. We then examined our top 15 authorship URLs (where author photos were known to show consistently) compared to non-authorship URLs.
The results broke down like seo audit tools this:
Change in Google organic traffic to Moz
Total Site: -1.76%
Top 15 Non-Authorship URLs: -5.96%
Top 15 Authorship URLs: -2.86%
Surprisingly, authorship URLs performed as well as non-authorship URLs in terms of traffic. Even though Moz was highly optimized for authors, traffic didn't significantly change.
On an individual level, things looked much different. We actually observed big changes in traffic with authorship URLs increasing or decreasing in traffic by as much as 45%. There is no clear pattern: Some went up, some went down—exactly like any URL would over an extended time.
Authorship photos don't exist in a vacuum; each photo on the page competed for attention with all the other photos on the page. Each search result is as unique as a fingerprint. What worked for one result didn't work for another.
Consider what happens visually when multiple author photos exist in the same search result:
One hypothesis speculates that more photos has the effect of drawing eyes down the page. In the absence of rich snippets, search click-through rates might follow more closely studied models, which dictate that results closer to the top earn more clicks.
In the absence of author photos, it's likely click-through rate expectations have once again become more standardized.
Video snippets: a complex tale
Shortly after Google removed author photos, they took aim at video snippets as well. On July 17th, MozCast reported a sharp decline in video thumbnails.
Most sites, Moz included, lost 100% of their video results. Other sites appeared to be "white-listed" as reported by former Mozzer Casey Henry at Wistia.
A few of the sites Casey found where Google continues to show video thumbnails:
Aside from these "giants," most webmasters, even very large publishers at the top of the industry, saw their video snippets vanish in search results.
How did this loss affect traffic for our URLs with embedded videos? Fortunately, here at Moz we have a large collection of ready-made video URLs we could easily study: our Whiteboard Friday videos, which we produce every, well, Friday.
To our surprise, most URLs actually saw more traffic.
On average, our Whiteboard Friday videos saw a 10% jump in organic traffic after losing video snippets.
A few other with video saw dramatic increases:
The last example, the Learn SEO page, didn't have http://www.ur-network.com/blog/tag/mutt-cutts an actual video on it, but a bug with Google caused them to display an older video thumbnail. (Several folks we've talked to speculate that Google removed video snippets simply to clean up their bugs in the system)
We witnessed a significant increase in traffic after losing video snippets. How did this happen?
Did Google change the way they rank and show video pages?
It turns out that many of our URLs that contained videos also saw a significant change in the number of search impressions at the exact same time.
According to Google, impressions for the majority of our video URLs shot up dramatically around July 14th.
Impressions for Whiteboard Friday URLs also rose 20% during this time. For Moz, most of the video URLs saw many more impressions, but for others, it appears rankings dropped.
While Moz saw video impressions rise, other publishers saw the opposite effect.
Casey Henry, our friend at video hosting company Wistia, reports seeing rankings drop for many video URLs that had thin or little content.
"...it's only pages hosting video with thin content... the pages that only had video and a little bit of text went down."
- Casey Henry
For a broader perspective, we talked to Marshall Simmonds, founder of Define Media Group, who monitors traffic to millions of daily video pageviews for large publishers.
Marshall found that despite the fact that most of the sites they monitor lost video snippets, they observed no visible change in either traffic or pageviews across hundreds of millions of visits.
Define Media Group also recently released its 2014 Mid-Year Digital Traffic Report which sheds fascinating light on current web traffic trends.
What does it all mean?
While we have anecdotal evidence of ranking and impression changes for video URLs on individual sites, on the grand scale across all Google search results these differences aren't visible.
If you have video content, the evidence suggests it's now worth more than http://www.ur-network.com/blog/tag/mutt-cutts ever to follow video SEO best practices: (taken from video SEO expert Phil Nottingham)
Use a crawlable player (all the major video hosting platforms use these today)
Surround the video with supporting information (caption files and transcripts work great)
Include schema.org video markup
SEO finds a way
For the past several years web marketers competed for image and video snippets, and it's with a sense of sadness that they've been taken away.
The smart strategy follows the data, which suggest that more traditional click-through rate optimization techniques and strategies could now be more effective. This means strong titles, meta descriptions, rich snippets (those that remain), brand building and traditional ranking signals.
What happened to your site when Google removed author photos and video snippets? Let us know in the comments below.
Why Most Seo Tools Fail
Every SEO expert confirms that doing SEO barehanded is just a deadend deal. SEO software makes the period consuming and meticulous work easier and much faster. There are a significant number of SEO resources made to assist every purpose of site optimization. You'll get a helping hand at each phase of SEO beginning with keyword analysis and finishing with all the investigation of the SEO campaign results.
Nowadays you can find a broad selection of no cost SEO tools available on the net. And this overview of the most used free SEO resources will enable you to get those that will make your site popularity rise.
Keywords lay the foundation stone of every SEO strategy. Hence keywords discovering and faceting is the initial stage on the road to the top of Google. Ofcourse you could placed on your thinking cap and make-up the listing of keywords all on your own. But as your ideas and the terms may significantly differ that is like a photo inthedark people genuinely input Google.
Here, Google AdWords Keyword Device comes in handy. Despite the fact that this tool is initially focused to aid Google AdWords advertisers, you can use that for keyword research also. Google AdWords Keyword Tool allows you to notice estimated traffic volumes, demonstrates your competitors for that chosen keywords, helps you discover which keywords to target and provides the listing of suggestions about common keywords. Google AdWords Keyword Device includes a people-friendly interface and moreover it is totally free. You can use various other settled alternate tools like Wordtracker or Keyword Breakthrough that could be successful as well, but Google AdWords Keyword Tool may be the supreme leader among free keyword research methods.
XML Sitemaps Machines
To ensure all of your pages get listed you ought to set sitemaps for your website and crawled. They are spider webs for Google spiders that enable them to easily find out what pages have been in location and those have already been recently updated -to- like ready. Sitemaps can be beneficial for individual visitors since they manage the complete construction of websiteis content and make website navigation a lot easier. The XML Sitemap Generator allows you to constitute XML, ROR sitemaps that can be submitted to Google, Yahoo! And lots of search engines. This SEO tool also allows you to make HTML sitemaps that enhance site navigation for individuals and create your website visitors-friendly.
The Rank Checker of sEO Book
To check on whether your optimization campaign is wasting cool or hot you will need a great position checking device to gauge the changes of one's website's ratings. SEO Book's Rank Checker could be of great aid in that. It's really a Chrome plug in that lets you manage examining rankings in Big Three: Google, Yahoo! And Bing and ship the collected data. All you've got to complete is enter you site's URL and the keywords you intend to examine your positions for. That is it and in some seconds SEO Bookis Rank Checker provides you with the outcome on your own rankings. It really is fast, simple-inuse and free.
Links are like beats in Google popularity game's ace. The idea is that the more quality links are on your backlink account the larger your.
Compete[ dot ] com provides a huge share of diagnostic information to fish from. It really is an on-line tool for tracking and evaluation of online competition that delivers two types of companies: free Website Statistics and subscription-based paid Search Analytics that allows you to take advantage of some extra capabilities. Compete an out-and-exterior SEO tool that allows you to notice proposal and traffic measurements to get a specific site and discover the sites for affiliating and link building applications. Participate can be an analyzer that is great, as it allows you to operate the analysis of the online competitors' keywords. Several other functions to mention are export to CSV, subdomain research, tagging etc.
SEO PowerSuite is all in-one SEO toolkit that enables you to cover all aspects of site optimization. It contains four SEO methods to nail all SEO projects. Site Auditor is a great calf- for creating smashing content on your website up. It analyzes you top works and out online rivals out a surefire plan on the basis of the greatest marketing techniques in your market. List Tracker is a superb at your site roles producing and monitoring one of the most click- profitable terms. SEO SpyGlass is powercharged SEO software for research and backlink checking. This is actually the only SEO software that allows you to discover 000 backlinks per a website to 50, up and produce reports with ready -to-use site optimization strategy. And the innovative within this line and the last is LinkAssistant. It's a featurerich giant SEO software for supervision and link creating that shoulders the key facets of offpage optimization.